Drink enough cream soda and you'll turn into one. A&W is pretty rad tho, so maybe turning into a cream soda ain't so bad, eh?

oh man, you gotta try Dad's Old Fashioned Cream Soda. It's way underrated and the nostalgia is real if you've been drinking cream sodas your whole life. Cheers to the soda quest!

You'll find many cream soda aficionados in this sub, and we've all got our favorites. What you tried is a solid mainstream option, but let's talk about craft sodas. One of the most interesting entries is Virgil's Handcrafted Cream Soda. It's micro-brewed with natural ingredients, and it's got a taste that sets it apart from the more commercial brands. The vanilla flavor is authentic, derived from actual vanilla beans, and the sweetness is balanced, not overpowering. Then there's Sparky's Fresh Draft Cream Soda, a rare find perhaps, but worth the hunt. It's creamy to the point where it might remind you of a smooth, vanilla soft-serve ice cream in a fizzy format. These sodas may not be as readily available as A&W, but they will elevate your cream soda experience to new heights.

Whatever you do, don't get the store brands thinking they're all the same. Spoiler: They're not. Seriously, stick to the craft sodas. Your taste buds will thank me later.

omg cream soda is my life!!! JUST tried Sprecher Cream Soda last week and it's life-changing!!! It's like liquid candy with a hint of honey. The vanilla is there but also something extra - maybe the Wisconsin honey they use? Anyway, it's super smooth!

Cream soda connoisseur here. You absolutely have to try Boylan's Cream Soda. It has a rich, vanilla, almost buttery flavor that's more complex than A&W. Also keep an eye out for IBC, another classic with a crisp taste and creamy finish. Regional sodas can also be a hidden gem – look for brands like Sioux City, Virgil's, or Jones Cream Soda. They've each got unique takes on the vanilla cream essence that defined this soda category.

Since you're digging A&W, definitely try Henry Weinhard's cream soda if you can find it. It's got a more gourmet flavor profile that might just set the new standard for ya!